Trump Cons, Cuomo Connects; Trump fails in talking to us
I’m a linguist by trade and I long ago grew weary of this spectator sport – hearing his overused superlatives (incredible, fantastic, perfect, huge); his word invention (Mexicans “criming here, criming there); his lack of any self-effacing or humble referents (“stable genius”, I know more about Isis than the generals do.); or his dizzying circular statements, “Well, I think these people always hit me with eminent domain, and frankly, I’m not in love with eminent domain. But eminent domain is something you need very strongly.”
Now in the grip of the Covid19 pandemic, I’ve found the bandwidth once again to listen to Coronavirus Task Force Meetings, only to hear Trump dragging the spoken word through the mud in the service of overtly bigoted, xenophobic and ego-wounded remarks delivered with passive anger to the American public.
One particular briefing reminded me of an astute observation one of my grad students made back in 2017. I was giving a grad seminar at my university on the linguistic characteristics of Trump Speak. Me focusing on the 3-5 grade readability score of most of his language; his haiku-like stream of non sequiturs – sort of like a comedy routine, minus the laughs. No lack of great language samples in my powerpoint.
And then a student hit the nail of the head. “Trump is just a bad storyteller. Nothing holds together. Ever.”
Why is it so important right now, when we’re exposed to and trying to consume so much new and often contradictory information about Covid19?
- Humans take in and process best in chunks, in short stories.
Listen to this story.
The King died. The Queen died.
We’re far more likely to remember and relate to the following story much more.
The King died and then the Queen died ….of grief.
It’s well studied and proven that a well constructed story ( no matter the length) yields better comprehension and recall. We simply learn through stories (Thorndyke; Van Dijk)
Or as Ira Glass (NPRs This American Life) sums up the power of story nicely. No matter how boring the facts are, with a well told story “you feel inherently as if you are on a train that has a destination.”
Good teachers, and good politicians know that a good story builds emotional and intellectual connections and can certainly persuade more than any straight facts.
Trump is a master twitter ( if we’re using sheer volume as the metric) but he cannot tell a good, coherent meaningful, memorable story.
What’s Trump missing:
· A story narrator has to connect with the listener and work to keep the listener’s attention – Trump can’t do that.
· A narrator chooses a point of view that advances the characters and plot. Trump’s narrator is always, always, first person “I”.
· A story needs a compelling character or characters, who develop over time. A character the listener cares about. Trump is the only character Trump is interested in.
· A story needs a plot – a beginning, middle and end. A logic. There’s very little logic in Trump’s discourse. He can’t create a narrative thread because he’s too intent on getting in his jabs – the name-calling and smack talk that hijacks the flow. Faulkner can weave a detoured story, Trump simply can’t.
· Building a story, even a short one, requires time and skill. Trump doesn’t have the attention span to thread the story (for stark contrast listen to Rachel Maddow on any night – a quintessential story teller). And he’s too busy ready to do verbal battle with every allusion or questioner in his path.
· A good story has a resolution, some closure. We listen for the ending. Trump’s stories all end the same way. I am perfect, a genius. They END.
Trump Example:
Here’s one recent example if you need convincing:
(Context) Over an hour into his Corona Task Force briefing March 22 2020, Trump is asked “Mr. President, did you sell stock?” (in reference to some legislators who dumped stock after a closed coronavirus update meeting). Yea it’s a poor question but Trump’s response is an example of Trump’s stories going off the rails. (forgive the format – it’s how CSPAN posts transcripts).
And his failure to communicate convincingly and memorably is now in sharp contrast to a master communicator –
Governor Andrew Cuomo.
“Also the federal funding, they’re working on another coronavirus bill – I was in Washington for eight years. This should not be the usual sausage making of pork barrel. When you do a piece of legislation in Washington, most legislators, it becomes the expression, “sausage making,” it becomes “pork barrel.” It goes through the political process, and the political process says everybody should get some money. Which dilutes the funding, gives it to communities and governments that don’t really need the funding and doesn’t even address the need, it’s one of the reasons people are suspect of government spending, right, because it winds up pork barrel. Every Senator is going to say, “I want money for my state.” Every congressperson says, “I want money for my local district. I want to be able to go home with a little package that I can hand to my local government.” That’s not what this is about in this case. This is about addressing a need and getting funding, precious funding, to people and places that need it. And the rule here should be, money follows the need. It’s that simple. What places need it? Self-serving, but New York State has 15 times more cases than any other state right now. Fund the states, fund the places that need it. Follow the number of cases, and use need as the basis for funding. It’s common sense. It would be respected by the people of this nation, and the alternative to politicize this funding process is intolerable.”
And today, talking about the human stress of social distancing:
“We are going to have time. And the question is how do we use this time positively?”…”Finding the silver lining, the positive. Life is going to be quieter for a matter of months. Everything will function. Life will function. Everything will normal operations, there won’t be chaos There’s less noise. You know what, that can be a good thing in some ways. You have more time. You have more flexibility. You can do some of those things that you haven’t done, that you kept saying, ‘Well I’d love to be able to, I’d love to be able to.’ Well now you can. You have more time with family.
“For myself, this young lady, Cara, is with me. She would never be here otherwise But I’m now going to be with Cara literally for a few months. What a beautiful gift that is, right? I would have never had that chance. And that is precious, and then after this is over she’s gone, she’s flown the nest. She’s going to go do her thing, but this crazy situation is crazy as it is, came with this beautiful gift. So one door closes, another door opens. Think about that. Realize the timeframe we’re expecting, make peace with it and find a way to help each other through this situation because it’s hard for everyone. And the goal for me – socially distanced but spiritually connected. How do you achieve socially distanced but spiritually connected?”
What a nice destination. No train wreck here.
All transcripts obtained as “quick transcripts”
Trump – https://www.c-span.org/